My Martha & Marley Spoon Review: Why I keep coming back to it

Update: I’ve tried a few other subscription services since my original Martha & Marley Spoon review and I still keep coming back to this service in particular. I also find that I recreate their recipes using my own ingredients because they’re so flavorful. If you’re looking for a meal service to try, I highly suggest giving this one a try. And no, I am not compensated for saying this!


You may have read that I’m addicted to subscription services. I mean, I can get great stuff without ever leaving my couch. Everything from cosmetics to wine to clothes (I have a love/hate relationship with Stitchfix). I tried Blue Apron recently but forgot to photograph everything. I also just received my first Try The World box which I can wait to play with (review to come).

I’ve been in a bit of a cooking funk lately so I thought I’d try a few of the meal subscriptions for inspiration. You know me, I LOVE to cook but sometimes I don’t want to have to think about it.

I decided to give Martha & Marley Spoon a try. I figured it’s Martha Stewart branding so it’s probably well done. So I wanted to share my Martha & Marley Spoon review with you.

My first impression: the packaging was not very enticing. I understand that she’s trying to be sustainable and all, but Blue Apron and Try the World had much more beautiful packaging. The brown bags just didn’t do it for me.

Martha & Marley Spoon packaging

Martha & Marley Spoon packaging


But the recipes looked great. In case you’ve never tried one of these subscription services, you do get some choices over the recipes you choose. Here are the three recipes I chose:

Martha & Marley Spoon recipes

Martha & Marley Spoon recipes


First, I made the Indonesian Chicken Kebabs. Caveat: I really don’t like chicken. I can only eat it if it’s really super spiced (so it hides the chicken flavor, I know…).  I unpacked the ingredients and the onion was a bit rotten. Fortunately, I had another one on hand.



Aside from chopping a few veggies and marinating the chicken, it was super simple and quick to make. Even the chicken was already cubed which I did not experience with Blue Apron or Hello Fresh. I was a little put off by the less-than-fresh onion, but it was time for the taste test.

It was awesome! I forgot to snap a pic but you can see the finished product in my picture above (and mine looked just like that. not.). But it was really flavorful to be such a simple dish.

The next night, I decided to give the Gluten-Free Goat Cheese Pasta a try.

IMG_6838 (1)


Again, it was another home run! Again, I forgot to take a finished product pic. Even my non-culinary-minded husband remarked about how much the fresh mint added to the dish. (He doesn’t know this was a subscription meal – he thinks I created it. He didn’t ask so I didn’t tell.) But I truly truly enjoyed this one and will be recreating it on my own. Lemon, goat cheese and mint! You can’t go wrong!

The next night I made the Pork Banh Mi Tacos and they were another huge flavor hit! Again, the produce was not so fresh. The carrot was half rotten so that was a disappointment but fortunately, I was able to use another carrot. But the tacos were really good, including the pickled veggies!

My final impression: the flavors were really really good on all three dishes and they were all something I would eat (make) again. The produce was a bit funky and tired. I did email Martha and Marley Spoon to let them know because it is a bit off-putting when you open the box.

Will I try it again? Maybe. My biggest problem with these subscription meal services is that 1) I don’t like tomatoes and SO many of the meals include them and 2) my hubby doesn’t like most veggies so I have to bridge that gap. But flavor wise? Yes! I’ll watch for a week when all of their menu choices fit my needs because I did find that Martha and Marley Spoon had the most flavor of any of the boxes I’ve tried.

Update: I’m trying out some new services, including Home Chef, so stay tuned for my new reviews! You can try Home Chef and get $30 off my clicking below.


This post may contain affiliate links.


You Might Also Like


  • Reply
    August 10, 2017 at 12:52 pm

    I’m giving Martha S a try; I’ve been with BA for quite a while and I’m starting to get bored. I’ll keep you posted as well. Thanks for your reviews. 🙂

  • Reply
    Tonya Johnson
    August 24, 2017 at 10:35 am

    Thank you for this honest review of Martha and Marly Spoon. I signed up for it and based on your review I know what to expect. One question, did it come in another box that contained some type of dry ice or other to keep it fresh and cold ?

    • Reply
      August 24, 2017 at 10:57 am

      Yes – it is shipped with ice packs to keep it cold for several hours.

  • Reply
    August 24, 2017 at 11:10 am

    The box contains two ice packs and then each meal is packaged in a paper bag. Well organized. I’m loving the meals so far. Quick and easy to prepare . I’m taking a break from blue apron meals.

  • Leave a Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial